Availability is US and was verified at the time of writing; check JustWatch for your region.
Scrooge (1951) is the best A Christmas Carol adaptation ever filmed, and The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) is the best one to own on Apple TV. Charles Dickens published A Christmas Carol in 1843, and filmmakers have been retelling it ever since, starting with the silent short Scrooge; or, Marley's Ghost in 1901.
This ranking covers the 17 major film and television versions you can still rent or buy in the US, sorted into four tiers. Every entry leads with where to own it, because the adaptations worth rewatching every December are the ones worth keeping in your library. If you like your ghost stories Victorian, our guide to [gothic and Victorian horror](INTERNAL LINK: The Best Gothic and Victorian Horror Movies, Ranked and Where to Own/Watch Them) makes a good next stop.
What Makes a Great Christmas Carol Adaptation? The Criteria Behind the Rankings
A great Christmas Carol adaptation does three things well: it casts a Scrooge whose change you believe, it lets the ghosts frighten as well as teach, and it keeps Dickens' anger about poverty in view. The rankings below weigh those three marks above budget, fame or nostalgia.
The Scrooge test matters most. Ebenezer Scrooge has to be cold enough in the first act that his Christmas morning feels earned, and the best performances (Alastair Sim, George C. Scott, Michael Caine) make the turn without winking at the audience. The ghost test asks whether Jacob Marley and the three spirits feel like a real haunting rather than a pageant. The Dickens test asks whether the adaptation remembers Ignorance and Want, the Cratchits' kitchen and the debtors, or only the bells and the turkey.
Faithfulness counts, but it does not decide everything. Scrooged moves the story to a 1980s television network and still ranks high because it passes all three tests in its own idiom.
How Many A Christmas Carol Adaptations Exist? The Full Scope of Dickens' Legacy
A Christmas Carol is one of the most adapted stories in the English language. IMDb lists more than 100 screen versions, and Penguin estimates hundreds of film and television adaptations, possibly more than 400, since the book appeared in 1843.
Most of those are television episodes, parodies and one-off specials. The ranked list below sticks to the major feature films, television films, animated specials and miniseries that a US reader can still rent or buy digitally. Adaptations that cannot currently be bought on a US digital storefront appear in the honorable mentions instead.
At a Glance: Every Ranked A Christmas Carol Adaptation
The table below lists all 17 ranked adaptations with each film's tier, its US digital ownership option and one key fact.
| Film | Year | Director | Tier | US platform | Key fact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scrooge | 1951 | Brian Desmond Hurst | Masterpiece | Amazon Video rent or buy (not on Apple TV) | 86 min; Alastair Sim |
| The Muppet Christmas Carol | 1992 | Brian Henson | Masterpiece | Apple TV rent or buy (4K) | 86 min; Michael Caine |
| A Christmas Carol | 1984 | Clive Donner | Masterpiece | Apple TV rent or buy | Emmy nomination for George C. Scott |
| Scrooged | 1988 | Richard Donner | Strong Contender | Apple TV rent or buy | 4K Blu-ray released Nov. 7, 2023 |
| Scrooge | 1970 | Ronald Neame | Strong Contender | Apple TV rent or buy | Four Academy Award nominations |
| A Christmas Carol | 1999 | David Hugh Jones | Strong Contender | Apple TV rent or buy | Premiered on TNT, Dec. 5, 1999 |
| Mickey's Christmas Carol | 1983 | Burny Mattinson | Strong Contender | Apple TV rent or buy | 26 min |
| A Christmas Carol | 1938 | Edwin L. Marin | Strong Contender | Apple TV rent or buy | 69 min; Reginald Owen |
| Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol | 1962 | Abe Levitow | Solid Middle | Apple TV rent or buy | 52 min |
| A Christmas Carol (FX) | 2019 | Nick Murphy | Solid Middle | Apple TV buy | Three-part miniseries |
| A Christmas Carol | 2009 | Robert Zemeckis | Solid Middle | Apple TV rent | 96 min; performance capture |
| Scrooge | 1935 | Henry Edwards | Solid Middle | Apple TV rent or buy | 78 min; Seymour Hicks |
| An American Christmas Carol | 1979 | Eric Till | Solid Middle | Apple TV rent or buy | Aired on ABC, Dec. 16, 1979 |
| A Christmas Carol: The Musical | 2004 | Arthur Allan Seidelman | Miss | Apple TV rent or buy | 22 songs; shot in Budapest |
| Ghosts of Girlfriends Past | 2009 | Mark Waters | Miss | Apple TV rent or buy | 100 min |
| The Stingiest Man in Town | 1978 | Jules Bass, Arthur Rankin Jr. | Miss | Apple TV rent | 50 min; Walter Matthau |
| A Flintstones Christmas Carol | 1994 | Joanna Romersa | Miss | Apple TV | 70 min |
Every A Christmas Carol Adaptation: The Complete Ranked List
Here is every major A Christmas Carol adaptation ranked from best to worst, grouped into four tiers, with where to own each one digitally.
The Unassailable Masterpieces: The Best Christmas Carol Films Ever Made
The best Christmas Carol films ever made are Scrooge (1951), The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) and George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (1984). Each one passes all three tests: a believable Scrooge, ghosts that frighten and Dickens' anger intact.
1. Scrooge (1951)
Director: Brian Desmond Hurst
Starring: Alastair Sim, Mervyn Johns, Michael Hordern, George Cole
Runtime: 86 min
Where to own (US): Not available to rent or buy on Apple TV. Rent or buy on Amazon Video. The US Blu-ray from VCI (released November 3, 2009) carries the film under its American title, A Christmas Carol.
Scrooge (1951), released in the US as A Christmas Carol, is the version every other adaptation gets measured against. Alastair Sim plays Ebenezer Scrooge as a man who chose loneliness and half knows it, and Brian Desmond Hurst's film gives the past sequences extra weight, so the miser's coldness has a history. Michael Hordern's Jacob Marley is a truly frightening opening act for a holiday film, and George Cole plays the young Scrooge whose hardening the film tracks scene by scene.
Best for: Christmas Eve after the house goes quiet, with the lights low.
The Screendollars Take
Scrooge is not the cozy holiday film you’d like it to be. It is a ghost story about regret that happens to end on Christmas morning. Sim's great choice is restraint: his Scrooge is brittle rather than monstrous, so when he finally laughs, giddy and slightly unhinged, the release feels earned. It is the one version that makes you believe a man could change overnight because it shows how long he spent becoming someone else.
2. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)
Director: Brian Henson
Starring: Michael Caine, Steve Whitmire, Dave Goelz, Frank Oz
Runtime: 86 min
Where to own (US): Rent ($3.99) or buy ($17.99) on Apple TV in 4K. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
The Muppet Christmas Carol is the most rewatchable adaptation of Dickens' story and the best one to own. Michael Caine plays Scrooge completely straight opposite Kermit the Frog's Bob Cratchit, and the Great Gonzo narrates as Charles Dickens himself, with Rizzo the Rat along to undercut him. Gonzo's narration quotes Dickens' prose directly, so the book's own language runs through the whole film. JustWatch also lists theatrical tickets at Harkins Theatres from December 4, 2026, so you can see it on a big screen before you add it to your library.
Best for: the first weekend of December, with the whole family on the couch.
The Screendollars Take
The Muppet Christmas Carol is like a parody. It is one of the most faithful versions ever made, wearing felt. Caine's decision to act as though he is in a serious period drama is the engine of the whole film, because every joke lands against a man who never treats the material as a joke. Few adaptations make Scrooge's redemption feel this joyful without cheapening it.
3. A Christmas Carol (1984)
Director: Clive Donner
Starring: George C. Scott, David Warner, Frank Finlay, Edward Woodward
Runtime: 101 min
Where to own (US): Rent ($3.99) or buy ($14.99) on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol is the most complete straight adaptation, and it earned Scott an Emmy nomination. The film aired on CBS on December 17, 1984, and played in British cinemas. Director Clive Donner had been an editor on the 1951 Scrooge, and his version has the same respect for the text, with a deep bench of British character actors: David Warner as Bob Cratchit, Frank Finlay as Marley and Edward Woodward as a booming Ghost of Christmas Present.
Best for: a Saturday night in mid-December when you want the full story told properly.
The Screendollars Take
Scott's Scrooge is not a frail old miser. He is a formidable businessman who can win any argument, which makes his surrender to the spirits more striking. Scott plays the early scenes as pure logic: Scrooge is not cruel for fun, he simply believes the poor are a math problem. The 1984 film is the version to show someone who has only seen the cartoons.
The Strong Contenders: Excellent Adaptations Worth Owning
The strong contenders are excellent adaptations that miss the top tier by a single test, and every one of them is worth owning.
4. Scrooged (1988)
Director: Richard Donner
Starring: Bill Murray, Karen Allen, Carol Kane, David Johansen
Runtime: 101 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home. A 4K Blu-ray was released on November 7, 2023.
Scrooged is the best modern retelling of A Christmas Carol. Bill Murray plays Frank Cross, a television executive staging a live broadcast of A Christmas Carol on Christmas Eve while being haunted by three ghosts of his own. Richard Donner pushes the comedy hard, with Carol Kane's violently affectionate Ghost of Christmas Present and David Johansen's Ghost of Christmas Past, but the film still follows Dickens' structure beat for beat.
Best for: a late-night double feature with the 1984 version, for the whiplash.
The Screendollars Take
Scrooged is not a spoof of Dickens. It is a satire of the people who would sell Dickens back to you between commercials. Murray spends most of the film as a sneering network boss and then delivers a closing speech that lands as the most sincere moment in his early career. It is the only adaptation here that is about A Christmas Carol as well as being one.
5. Scrooge (1970)
Director: Ronald Neame
Starring: Albert Finney, Alec Guinness, Edith Evans, Kenneth More
Runtime: 114 min
Where to own (US): Rent ($3.99) or buy ($14.99) on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
Scrooge (1970) is the best musical adaptation of A Christmas Carol. Albert Finney plays the miser under heavy old-age makeup, Alec Guinness floats in as Marley's ghost, and Leslie Bricusse's songs include "Thank You Very Much," one of the film's four Academy Award nominations. Ronald Neame shot it in London in 1970 on a grand scale, and Finney won a Golden Globe for the role.
Best for: a December afternoon with a mug of something warm and the volume up.
The Screendollars Take
Scrooge is not a stately costume drama with songs bolted on. It is a full-blooded British musical that trusts its lead to be unpleasant. Finney's "I Hate People" is funnier and nastier than any big-studio musical had a right to be, and his grubby, muttering miser gives the joyful second half somewhere to climb from.
6. A Christmas Carol (1999)
Director: David Hugh Jones
Starring: Patrick Stewart, Richard E. Grant, Joel Grey
Runtime: 97 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol, which premiered on TNT on December 5, 1999, grew out of the one-man stage versions Stewart performed on Broadway and in London. Richard E. Grant plays Bob Cratchit and Joel Grey is an eerie Ghost of Christmas Past. The film keeps the grim tone of the 1951 version and gives Stewart room for the slow, physical breakdown that his stage show was built around.
Best for: a weeknight when you want the faithful version in under 100 minutes.
The Screendollars Take
Stewart's Scrooge is not angry. He is hollow, a man who has forgotten how to laugh and has to relearn it in front of us. Watching him relearn how to laugh on Christmas morning is the best single acting choice in any television adaptation of the story.
7. Mickey's Christmas Carol (1983)
Director: Burny Mattinson
Starring: Alan Young, Wayne Allwine
Runtime: 26 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
Mickey's Christmas Carol is the best short adaptation and the easiest way to introduce young children to the story. Disney cast Scrooge McDuck as Ebenezer Scrooge, Mickey Mouse as Bob Cratchit and Goofy as Jacob Marley's ghost, and Burny Mattinson's 26-minute film still covers the full arc from counting house to Christmas morning.
Best for: the kids' bedtime on Christmas Eve, when you have exactly half an hour.
The Screendollars Take
Mickey's Christmas Carol is not a watered-down version. It is a compressed one, and the compression works because every Disney character arrives with a personality you already know. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sequence at the graveside is scarier than it has any right to be in a cartoon starring Goofy.
8. A Christmas Carol (1938)
Director: Edwin L. Marin
Starring: Reginald Owen, Gene Lockhart, Terry Kilburn, Leo G. Carroll
Runtime: 69 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
MGM's A Christmas Carol (1938) is the classic Hollywood version. Lionel Barrymore was set to play Scrooge, but illness forced him to withdraw, and Reginald Owen, originally cast as Marley, took the lead. MGM rushed the film into production in October 1938 and finished it in a matter of weeks, which shows in its brisk 69 minutes.
Best for: a short, sweet watch on Christmas morning after the presents.
The Screendollars Take
The 1938 film is the definitive Christmas Carol. It is the friendliest one, a warm MGM family picture that softens Scrooge's edges and leans on the Cratchits' kitchen. Gene Lockhart's Bob Cratchit, cheerfully losing his job and still buying the goose, is the film's real heart.
The Solid Middle: Decent Takes on the Classic Tale
The solid middle holds adaptations with a strong idea or a strong lead but a clear weakness that keeps them out of the top half.
9. Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol (1962)
Director: Abe Levitow
Starring: Jim Backus
Runtime: 52 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home. Universal released it on Blu-ray on November 19, 2019.
Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol frames the story as a Broadway show starring the near-sighted Mr. Magoo, voiced by Jim Backus, as Scrooge. Abe Levitow's 52-minute special plays the material surprisingly straight once the curtain rises, and its songs are still a seasonal favorite for viewers who grew up with it.
Best for: a nostalgic evening with anyone who watched it on network television.
The Screendollars Take
Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol is not a Magoo cartoon with Dickens on the side. It is a musical Dickens adaptation that happens to star Magoo, and the gag-free middle stretch is braver than its premise suggests.
10. A Christmas Carol (2019)
Director: Nick Murphy
Starring: Guy Pearce, Andy Serkis, Stephen Graham
Runtime: 3 episodes, 2 hr 52 min
Where to own (US): Buy on Apple TV. Also buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
FX's A Christmas Carol, written by Steven Knight and premiering on FX on December 19, 2019, is the darkest reimagining on this list. Guy Pearce plays a younger, colder Scrooge, Stephen Graham's Marley is trapped in a purgatory of his own, and Andy Serkis plays the Ghost of Christmas Past. The three-part miniseries rebuilds Scrooge's backstory from the ground up, and it carries a TV-MA rating.
Best for: adults only, after the kids are asleep, across two December nights.
The Screendollars Take
FX's version is not a family Christmas Carol. It is a grim character study that borrows Dickens' skeleton. Pearce commits fully, and the craft is strong, but by inventing so much new backstory the series loses the book's simplest idea: that ordinary selfishness is enough to damn a man.
11. A Christmas Carol (2009)
Director: Robert Zemeckis
Starring: Jim Carrey, Gary Oldman, Colin Firth
Runtime: 96 min
Where to own (US): Rent on Apple TV. Buy on Amazon Video or Fandango At Home, which also rents it.
Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) uses performance capture to let Jim Carrey play Scrooge at every age and all three ghosts, with Gary Oldman as Bob Cratchit, Marley and Tiny Tim and Colin Firth as Fred. Robert Zemeckis follows Dickens' dialogue closely but stages the ghost sequences as theme-park rides.
Best for: a big-screen TV and a group that wants spectacle more than sentiment.
The Screendollars Take
Zemeckis's film is not a failure of faithfulness. It is a failure of faces: the performance-capture characters look almost human, which makes them hard to read in quiet scenes. Carrey's Scrooge is committed and often sharp, but the film is most alive when it stops talking and starts flying.
12. Scrooge (1935)
Director: Henry Edwards
Starring: Seymour Hicks
Runtime: 78 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
Scrooge (1935) is the British sound-era version, starring Seymour Hicks, who had already played Scrooge in a 1913 silent film. Henry Edwards' adaptation is the earliest feature on this list, and it keeps several of Dickens' scenes that later versions cut.
Best for: a classic-film night for viewers who like to see where the tradition started.
The Screendollars Take
The 1935 Scrooge is a museum piece. It is a return engagement, with Hicks playing a role he had first played on film in 1913. The film is creaky in places, but his Christmas morning glee is the template that later Scrooges borrowed.
13. An American Christmas Carol (1979)
Director: Eric Till
Starring: Henry Winkler, David Wayne, Dorian Harewood
Runtime: 98 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home. A Blu-ray was released in December 2012.
An American Christmas Carol moves the story to Depression-era New Hampshire, with Henry Winkler, then famous as the Fonz, playing a heartless finance company president named Benedict Slade. The ABC television film aired on December 16, 1979, and Academy Award-winning makeup artist Rick Baker consulted on Winkler's aging makeup.
Best for: a Sunday afternoon when you want a fresh setting for a familiar story.
The Screendollars Take
An American Christmas Carol is not a gimmick. The Depression setting makes the stakes of debt and unemployment feel immediate in a way the Victorian versions sometimes lose. Winkler is too young for the role and the makeup shows it, but the film's anger about debt is closer to Dickens than its premise suggests.
The Misses: Adaptations That Fell Short of Dickens' Vision
These adaptations fall short of Dickens' vision, usually because they keep the story's structure and lose its fear or its conscience.
14. A Christmas Carol: The Musical (2004)
Director: Arthur Allan Seidelman
Starring: Kelsey Grammer, Jason Alexander, Jane Krakowski, Jesse L. Martin
Runtime: 87 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
A Christmas Carol: The Musical brought a stage musical with lyrics by Lynn Ahrens to NBC on November 28, 2004. Kelsey Grammer stars as Scrooge, Jason Alexander plays Marley, and the film was shot in Budapest with a score of 22 songs.
Best for: theater fans who already know the stage show.
The Screendollars Take
The 2004 musical is not short on talent. It is short on danger. Grammer sings well and the supporting cast is strong, but the film plays every ghost for pageantry, so Scrooge never seems to be in real peril. It falls short of Dickens because nothing here frightens.
15. Ghosts of Girlfriends Past (2009)
Director: Mark Waters
Starring: Matthew McConaughey, Jennifer Garner, Michael Douglas
Runtime: 100 min
Where to own (US): Rent or buy on Apple TV. Also rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
Ghosts of Girlfriends Past turns A Christmas Carol into a wedding-weekend romantic comedy. Matthew McConaughey plays Connor Mead, a womanizing photographer visited by the ghosts of his romantic past, present and future, with Michael Douglas as the late uncle who taught him his bad habits. Mark Waters' film opened in theaters on May 1, 2009.
Best for: a romantic-comedy night when you want the lightest possible twist on the story.
The Screendollars Take
Ghosts of Girlfriends Past is not really a Christmas Carol. It is a romantic comedy that borrows the three-ghost structure as a gimmick. Michael Douglas is fun as the Marley figure, but the film keeps Dickens' frame and drops his conscience, which is why it lands among the misses.
16. The Stingiest Man in Town (1978)
Director: Jules Bass, Arthur Rankin Jr.
Starring: Walter Matthau, Tom Bosley, Theodore Bikel
Runtime: 50 min
Where to own (US): Rent on Apple TV. Also rent on Amazon Video.
The Stingiest Man in Town is Rankin/Bass's animated remake of a 1956 live television musical, with Walter Matthau voicing Scrooge and Tom Bosley narrating as B.A.H. Humbug. It aired on December 23, 1978, and the animation comes from the Japanese studio Topcraft.
Best for: Rankin/Bass completists working through the holiday specials.
The Screendollars Take
The Stingiest Man in Town is a lost classic. It is a solid score in search of a better film. Matthau's grumbling Scrooge is a smart idea, but the cutesy narrator keeps interrupting the story just as it gathers weight.
17. A Flintstones Christmas Carol (1994)
Director: Joanna Romersa
Starring: Henry Corden
Runtime: 70 min
Where to own (US): Available on Apple TV. Also on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
A Flintstones Christmas Carol casts Fred Flintstone as Scrooge in a Bedrock Community Players stage production while Fred acts stingy in real life. The special premiered in syndication on November 21, 1994.
Best for: young Flintstones fans on a lazy December morning.
The Screendollars Take
A Flintstones Christmas Carol is not a bad idea. A play within a cartoon is a clever way to show Fred learning the lesson he is performing. The execution is thin, though, and the Dickens scenes play as sketches between Bedrock gags.
The Definitive Scrooges: Ranking the Actors Who Played Ebenezer Scrooge
Alastair Sim is the definitive Ebenezer Scrooge. His 1951 performance balances cruelty, fear and finally joy better than any other, and every later Scrooge is compared with it. Here is how the major Scrooges in this ranking line up, from best to least.
- Alastair Sim (Scrooge, 1951): The benchmark: brittle, haunted and finally giddy.
- George C. Scott (A Christmas Carol, 1984): The most commanding Scrooge, a businessman who can win every argument until the spirits arrive.
- Michael Caine (The Muppet Christmas Carol, 1992): A straight dramatic performance surrounded by puppets, and better for it.
- Patrick Stewart (A Christmas Carol, 1999): The most interior Scrooge, built from years of performing the story on stage.
- Albert Finney (Scrooge, 1970): The nastiest and funniest, and the only one who sings "I Hate People."
- Bill Murray (Scrooged, 1988): A modern Scrooge whose closing speech is the most sincere moment of his early career.
- Reginald Owen (A Christmas Carol, 1938): A gentler studio Scrooge who stepped in when Lionel Barrymore fell ill.
- Guy Pearce (A Christmas Carol, 2019): The coldest Scrooge, in the darkest version.
- Jim Carrey (A Christmas Carol, 2009): Committed and sharp, but hidden behind performance capture.
- Kelsey Grammer (A Christmas Carol: The Musical, 2004): A fine singer in a production that never puts him in danger.
A Christmas Carol by Format: Live-Action, Animation, Muppets, and Modern Retellings
The best A Christmas Carol adaptation in each format is Scrooge (1951) for live action, Mickey's Christmas Carol for animation, Scrooged for modern retellings and The Muppet Christmas Carol, which deserves a category of its own.
The Best Live-Action A Christmas Carol Adaptations
The best live-action adaptations are Scrooge (1951), George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (1984) and Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol (1999). All three keep Dickens' Victorian setting and most of his dialogue, and all three are available to own digitally, with the 1984 and 1999 films on Apple TV.
The Best Animated A Christmas Carol Films
Mickey's Christmas Carol (1983) is the best animated Christmas Carol you can own today, followed by Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol (1962) and Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009). Richard Williams' Academy Award-winning 1971 short, often called the finest animated version, is not currently sold on a US digital storefront, so it sits in the honorable mentions.
The Best Modern Retellings and Reimaginings (Scrooged, The Man Who Invented Christmas, FX's A Christmas Carol)
Scrooged (1988) is the best modern retelling, followed by FX's A Christmas Carol (2019) and An American Christmas Carol (1979). Each moves or darkens the story while keeping Dickens' three-ghost structure.
The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017) is not ranked here because it is a film about Dickens writing the book rather than an adaptation of the story itself. It makes a good companion piece for anyone who wants the history behind the tale.
The Muppet Christmas Carol: Why It Deserves Its Own Category
The Muppet Christmas Carol deserves its own category because it is both a family comedy and one of the most faithful adaptations ever made. Gonzo narrates as Charles Dickens and quotes the book's prose directly, Michael Caine plays Scrooge as straight drama, and the film is available to rent or buy in 4K on Apple TV.
The Best A Christmas Carol Adaptations by Decade
The best A Christmas Carol adaptation of each era is Scrooge (1951) for the classic years, George C. Scott's 1984 film for the television era and FX's 2019 miniseries for the modern era.
The 1930s to 1950s: The Golden Age of Classic Hollywood Scrooge
The best Christmas Carol of Hollywood's classic era is Scrooge (1951), with MGM's A Christmas Carol (1938) and the British Scrooge (1935) close behind. All three are black-and-white, all three run under 90 minutes, and together they set the visual vocabulary of fog, chains and candlelit counting houses that later versions still borrow.
The 1970s to 1990s: The Television Special Era
The 1970s to 1990s produced the best television adaptations, led by George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (1984), which aired on CBS, and Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol (1999), which premiered on TNT. The era also gave us Scrooge (1970), Mickey's Christmas Carol (1983), Scrooged (1988) and The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992), making it the richest period for the story on screen.
The 2000s to 2020s: CGI, Dark Reimaginings, and New Classics
The 2000s to 2020s brought performance capture, dark reimaginings and new formats. Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) used performance capture, FX's A Christmas Carol (2019) turned the story into an adult miniseries, and A Christmas Carol: The Musical (2004) brought the stage musical to network television.
Where to Own A Christmas Carol Adaptations Digitally
You can own 16 of the 17 ranked A Christmas Carol adaptations on Apple TV, and the remaining one, Scrooge (1951), on Amazon Video.
Best Digital Platforms to Buy A Christmas Carol Movies
Apple TV is the best place to buy A Christmas Carol adaptations digitally, because it carries 16 of the 17 ranked versions to rent or buy, including The Muppet Christmas Carol in 4K. Amazon Video and Fandango At Home carry most of the same titles as alternatives.
The one major gap is Scrooge (1951), which is not on Apple TV and is available to rent or buy on Amazon Video. Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) is available only to rent on Apple TV, and the FX miniseries and The Stingiest Man in Town are sold in one format only (buy and rent, respectively).
Where to Stream A Christmas Carol Adaptations This Holiday Season
Several adaptations are also included with subscriptions this season: The Muppet Christmas Carol, Mickey's Christmas Carol and Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) on Disney+, FX's A Christmas Carol (2019) on Hulu and George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (1984) on MGM+. Subscription catalogs rotate quickly, though, and owning a copy is the only way to guarantee the version you want is there on Christmas Eve.
Essential Blu-ray and 4K UHD Collector's Editions
The essential physical editions are Scrooged on 4K UHD Blu-ray (released November 7, 2023), VCI's Blu-ray of Scrooge (1951, released November 3, 2009), Universal's Blu-ray of Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol (released November 19, 2019) and the 2012 Blu-ray of An American Christmas Carol.
None of the ranked adaptations has a Criterion Collection edition. For 4K picture quality without a disc, The Muppet Christmas Carol is sold in 4K on Apple TV, Amazon Video and Fandango At Home.
The Most Faithful Adaptation vs. the Best Film: Are They the Same?
The most faithful adaptation and the best film are not the same, but they are close. George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (1984) and Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol (1999) follow the book most completely, while Scrooge (1951) takes a few liberties with Scrooge's backstory and is still the better film.
The Muppet Christmas Carol complicates the question, because its narrator quotes Dickens' actual prose throughout. Scrooged does the opposite, changing nearly every surface detail while keeping the story's moral spine. Faithfulness to the text and faithfulness to the spirit are different tests, and the best adaptations pass the second one.
Honorable Mentions: Christmas Carol Adaptations That Just Missed the Rankings
These adaptations just missed the rankings because they cannot currently be bought on a US digital storefront, are only included with a subscription, or are not adaptations of the story itself.
- A Christmas Carol (1971): Richard Williams' 25-minute animated short, with Alastair Sim returning as Scrooge's voice, won the Academy Award for Best Animated Short Film. It is not currently sold on a US digital storefront.
- Blackadder's Christmas Carol (1988): Rowan Atkinson's 43-minute BBC special inverts the story, with a kind man learning to be nasty. In the US it is only available to buy on Fandango At Home.
- Carol for Another Christmas (1964): Joseph L. Mankiewicz's television film, written by Rod Serling and starring Sterling Hayden, recasts the ghosts as a warning about isolationism. It currently streams on HBO Max.
- Spirited (2022): Will Ferrell and Ryan Reynolds star in a musical told from the ghosts' side. It is an Apple TV+ subscription title rather than a store purchase.
- Christmas Carol: The Movie (2001): Jimmy T. Murakami's animated film with Simon Callow, Kate Winslet and Nicolas Cage is available to rent or buy only on Amazon Video.
- Ms. Scrooge (1997): Cicely Tyson's USA Network version, set in Providence, Rhode Island, has no US streaming or purchase option at the time of writing.
Final Verdict: The Single Greatest A Christmas Carol Adaptation to Own
The single greatest A Christmas Carol adaptation is Scrooge (1951), and the greatest one to own on Apple TV is The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992). Sim's film is the definitive version of the story, but it is only sold digitally on Amazon Video and on Blu-ray, while the Muppets version is available to rent or buy in 4K on Apple TV.
If you own only one, own the Muppets for the family and add Scrooge (1951) the moment you want the real chill. For more ideas, browse our [hidden gems on every streaming platform](INTERNAL LINK: Hidden Gems on Every Streaming Platform).





